NULLIUS Coherence Truth Board

Baseline: Firmenich et al. 2026 HEOM, gamma=7.69e13 Hz, tau_coh=13 fs @310K · Generated by kryptorious-qbio-coherence (NULLIUS)
READ THIS FIRST. The dephasing floor used here (Firmenich et al. 2026, γ=7.69×1013 Hz, τcoh=13 fs @310K) is a PREPRINT (publisher: openRxiv; type: posted-content; dated 2026-05-13) — not a peer-reviewed journal article. It is reproducible and widely cited, but if a replication moves the floor, every stored verdict must be re-verified. Treat verdicts as screening judgments, not settled fact.
SURVIVES: 4 FALSIFIED: 2 UNTESTED: 0
VerdictClaimKindClaimed ProtAllowedRatioMechanism
FALSIFIED MT bare electronic (Firmenich null)
Firmenich et al. 2026, HEOM, 1JFF Trp network @310K		 electronic 13.0 fs x1 13.0 fs 1 none (dephasing floor)
FALSIFIED MT Orch-OR functional coherence (naive)
Hameroff-Penrose Orch-OR (various); unspecified mechanism		 electronic 1000000.0 fs x1 13.0 fs 7.7e+04 none declared
SURVIVES MT collective-mode protection (N=1000)
Gross & Haroche 1982; Zurek 2009; audit ATP_QEC_DEPHASING_AUDIT.md		 electronic 400.0 fs x31.6 411.2 fs 0.97 collective-mode / Quantum Darwinism (1/sqrt N)
SURVIVES Avian compass (radical pair)
Ritz et al. 2000; Hore & Mouritsen 2016; Kritman et al. 2025 (Zeno)		 spin 1000000000.0 fs x10 10000000000.0 fs 0.1 hyperfine protection (quantum needle) + quantum Zeno
SURVIVES Photosynthetic EET (FMO)
Engel et al. 2007; Panitchayangkoon et al. 2010		 electronic 600.0 fs x47.6 619.3 fs 0.97 environment-assisted transport / structured bath (ENAQT)
SURVIVES Collagen-piezo proton tunneling (Stark-shifted)
Mana dissertation (Kryptorious QB KB); speculative		 electronic 50.0 fs x3.16 41.1 fs 1.2 collagen piezoelectric field Stark modulation